siameze22

7 years ago

I thought this book was great! My best friend in real life frostberriecat2 loves this series so do I!

kajackson8

8 years ago

this book is very interesting i recommend it to any cat love that wonders what the family cat thinks of

gouk

9 years ago

like,i lov that book

katherinec

9 years ago

I would give this book a 4 star as well as its last two book I read. This time the book still continued the life of fireheart, but however, this book was more into the main story than the last two. This time Fireheart discovered some other “interesting” news about other clans, and he decide to disobey the rule, and he sneak off to search what exactly happened. With the story ending with disappointment, leaving, and as well as heartbroken. I like this book’s plot as well, it is kind of intense when you read to the part where Fireheart decided to sneak out the clan. I like how the story goes into the plot, and the story itself is interesting. I would like to read it again and again and again until I can’t, haha. I think this will be a great book if you just want to relax yourself before heading off to bed. I recommend it for fourth graders, and it’s really a nice book.

moorhouse

9 years ago

this was the last book i read of this series and i hope to continue soon because i really like this series and its author Erin hunter did a great job

ball8628

9 years ago

This book is amazing. It really engages the reader into the life of a wild cat. VERY GOOD. READ THIS SERIES

zimandgir

10 years ago

It is such a great book graystripe and silverstream are so cute

key789

10 years ago

I!!!!!!!! LOVED!!!!!!!!!! THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BOOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It was so sad yet pretty grat and every one should read it!!!! Graystripe leaves the clan. silverstream dies and fireheart becomes deputy.

efurr7119

10 years ago

i know right

meltdown12

10 years ago

the new cover is OK but the book is GREAT

marisa

10 years ago

This book is very interesting and makes you wonder what will happen next!